"Hybrid Theory made me realise metal wasn't this weird, ostracised subgenre": Of Mice & Men's Aaron Pauley picks the 10 records that changed his life

Of Mice & Men Aaron Pauley
(Image credit: Press/SharpTone)

Aaron Pauley had already proven his vocal prowess before he joined Of Mice & Men in 2012. The singer of post-hardcore group Jamie's Elsewhere, Pauley was initially drafted as a temporary bassist before joining the band permanently in time for 2014's Restoring Force, contributing clean vocals that helped propel the album to a top 10 position on the US Billboard charts.

Stepping up as the band's frontman in 2016 after the departure of Austin Carlile, Pauley has since been the powerhouse behind the band's buoyant metalcore bangers. With new album Tether out in the world, we caught up with Pauley to find out which records set him on the path to following his passion. 

Metal Hammer line break

Papa Roach - Infest (2000)

Papa Roach are and I from the same small town in Northern California; our families went to the same church. When Last Resort became a worldwide phenomenon, that was a tangible thing to latch onto for inspiration: that you can make something that changes the world even if you’re from Vacaville. It was super-inspirational to me pursuing music."

You may like

Tool - Aenima (1996)

"Ænema was probably my first exposure to Tool. It exposed me to their whole catalogue and made me want to learn about music theory. It ignited a curiosity to learn more so I could create those things. Nobody does it like them – they create musical odysseys that are complex but you can still follow."


The Mars Volta - De-Loused in the Comatorium (2006)

“I heard Inertiatic ESP by The Mars Volta at the end of freshman year in high school. My buddy gave me the CD and said, ‘You gotta listen to this!’ The experimental nature of that record, plus the way that it’s mixed, means you can define every instrument and every member doing something. I was still recording on a little dictaphone and it opened my eyes to how you can mix and produce."


Sigur Rós - Takk... (2005)

"Sæglópur by Sigur Rós showed me you don’t really need words to tell a story. It’s a very emotionally rich listen, it evokes a lot of feelings. Sigur Rós are an amazing example of honing in on the universal language of music… Listening to that song reminds me of driving round my hometown when it’s rainy."


Pressure 4-5 - Burning The Process (2001)

"I listened to Pieces by Pressure 4-5 a bunch when I was in eighth and ninth grade. I’d just moved away from my middle school best friends [in Clearlake] back to my hometown [of Vacaville], I was readjusting. I hadn’t gone back to school or made friends yet. It felt like company when I was skateboarding alone, before we had iPods."


Linkin Park - Hybrid Theory (2000)

“I got into heavy music a year or two before One Step Closer by Linkin Park came out. When it came out, I remember thinking, ‘This is amazing!’ And then the whole world basically decided the same thing. That was the first time I’d ever seen heavy music that I liked connect with so many people. I thought, ‘Oh man, people get this! It’s not this weird, ostracised subgenre! People are starting to understand what this music is about because of this song.’"


Slipknot - Iowa (2001)

"When Slipknot's Left Behind debuted on MTV, that was the first time me and my friends all planned and waited on something related to being a fan of a band, or heavy music in general. We knew when it was premiering; we were all gonna be at my house because we had the music channel, we set it to record. I remember we watched it with my parents and they were like, ‘Jesus Christ! This is what you kids are listening to?!’"


Norma Jean - Bless The Martyr And Kiss The Child (2002)

“Norma Jean’s Memphis Will Be Laid To Waste reminds me of hardcore dancing in high school! That was in the age of making playlists, with HXCMP3 and Pure Volume, all those websites. This song was on every playlist – it’s such a classic vintage banger. It reminds me of friends sharing music we’d discovered from those websites. It’s one of the most important historical songs for where this all came from


Converge - Jane Doe (2001)

"Concubine by Converge is quintessential; it reminds me of my friends and I in our local band, driving around in the van and hoping it didn’t break down. It’s pure unbridled rage, and the emphasis is on teetering between being more organised and being chaotic. It was really formative too for me, because it made me realise you can make extremely chaotic music that’s easy to follow because there’s that tangible emotional thread."


Mansions - Dig Up The Dead (2011)

“Me and my buddies used to play Mansions’ Dig Up The Dead acoustically and sing it with each other. It reminds me of being with them, drinking whiskey and singing sad songs. We’re like trees that keep growing, and songs carve their initials in us. We get older and more weathered, but some of them cut deep and you still see them there.”

Will Marshall
Writer

Will's been a metal obsessive ever since hearing Trivium’s Ascendancy way back in 2005, and it's been downhill ever since. Since joining the Metal Hammer team in 2021, he’s penned features with the likes of rising stars Lake Malice, Scowl and Drain, and symphonic legends Epica. He’s also had bylines in Stereoboard, covering everything from Avenged Sevenfold to Charli XCX.

Read more
Brat press pic
"My first concert was The Black Crowes, but my second was ZZ Top. That would've been the cooler answer!" Brat's Liz Selfish: 10 Records That Changed My Life
Linkin Park/Slipknot/Evanescence/Korn/Kittie
"It’s actually Sid Wilson’s favourite Slipknot song." Inside nu metal's greatest deep cuts
Chris Motionless Motionless In White
"People are baffled if I say I love Taylor Swift." Modern metalcore icon Chris Motionless on being a Swiftie, ice hockey and why Motionless In White are taking their time on a new album
Fit For An Autopsy press shot 2024
"We saw Sleep Token in Glasgow. 14,000, sold out. It just makes me hungry." Deathcore heroes Fit For An Autopsy have their sights on being extreme metal's biggest band
Killswitch Engage Jesse Leach
"My dad smashed the tape of Number Of The Beast: ‘I’m forbidding Devil’s music in my house!’ That only made it more appealing.” How Jesse Leach went from "Flanders kid" to future metalcore icon
Papa Roach 2024
"We have lost friends, to ODs, suicide. And we see each other out there still holding it down." How Papa Roach survived the rise and fall of nu metal to be bigger than ever in 2024
Latest in
Vera Farmiga in 2021
The Conjuring star Vera Farmiga announces debut album with her heavy metal band The Yagas
'Emo' Ed Sheeran busking
Watch Ed Sheeran cover Chappell Roan's Pink Pony Club on the New York subway while disguised as an emo busker
A close-up shot of the Marshall Major IV on-ear headphones on a turquoise, blue and black background.
I’ve never seen the Marshall Major IV headphones this cheap before - get them for half price in Amazon’s big spring sale
Evanescence in 2025
Evanescence release new song Afterlife from Devil May Cry TV series soundtrack, have their next album in the works
Tony Banks
“You only have to hear the opening sweep to reach for your lighter and wave it in the air”: Tony Banks' greatest Genesis moments
The Horrors
Ghouls Aloud: The Horrors come back from the dead with "a dazzling nocturnal spectacle of sombre reflections and oozing catharsis"
Latest in Features
Tony Banks
“You only have to hear the opening sweep to reach for your lighter and wave it in the air”: Tony Banks' greatest Genesis moments
Rick Astley and Rick Wakeman
“Rick Wakeman’s solo albums were just brilliant… when I heard he was doing Henry VIII at Hampton Court Palace, I bought 12 tickets”: Prog is the reason Rick Astley became a singer
Ozzy Osbourne, Paul McCartney, Robert Plant, Jim Morrison and Joe Strummer onstage
The greatest gig I've ever seen: 24 writers pick the most memorable live show of their lives
Marillion in 1984
From debauched prog revivalists to pioneers of the internet age: The Marillion albums you should definitely listen to
Mogwai
“The concept of cool and uncool is completely gone, which is good and bad… people are unashamedly listening to Rick Astley. You’ve got to draw a line somewhere!” Mogwai and the making of prog-curious album The Bad Fire
The Mars Volta
“My totalitarian rule might not be cool, but at least we’ve made interesting records. At least we polarise people”: It took The Mars Volta three years and several arguments to make Noctourniquet