“It felt like there were dark times hanging over this album”: How hard rock supergroup Chickenfoot restarted the party on their second album, III

Chickenfoot posing for a photograph in 2011
(Image credit: Press)

Featuring Sammy Hager, Michael Anthony and Joe Satriani, Chickenfoot were one of the great good-time supergroups of the 21st century. In 2011, as they geared up to release their misleadingly-titled second album, III, Classic Rock caught up with the trio.

Classic Rock divider

It was one of those gigs you’d bore your kids about for years to come. February 2008, the Palms Casino Resort in Las Vegas. Sammy Hagar – the Red Rocker, tequila proprietor, club impresario – is rocking the Pearl Concert Theater with his band the Waboritas. The night’s in full, loud swing, Cabo Wabo style. His buddy and former Van Halen bandmate Michael Anthony digs into his Jack Daniel’s design bass. Cocktail waitresses cut their way through the sweaty audience. Some fans are even up on the stage, rocking out with the band. Good times.

For the encore the singer calls up two special guests. Red Hot Chili Peppers drummer Chad Smith gets behind the kit, and the guy Hagar calls the best guitarist in the world, Joe Satriani, steps up and plugs in his Ibanez. Together they rip through I’m Going Down and Traffic’s Dear Mr Fantasy and the place goes wilder. They sign off with Led Zeppelin’s Rock And Roll. A supergroup is born.

You may like

“Something happened,” Joe Satriani tells Classic Rock. “We all came off the stage wide-eyed and very excited. This super-chemistry had popped into being. I got together with Sam a few days later to see if we really could write, and in 45 minutes we had six pieces that were almost complete.”

That year, Satriani was touring his album Professor Satchafunkilus And The Musterion Of Rock, but he and Hagar continued to write via iPhone and email, all the while sending demos to Anthony and Smith. Eventually the four convened at George Lucas’s Skywalker Sound studio and recorded their debut album. Kicking off with the spunky romp Oh Yeah, the album, Chickenfoot, was a sleeper hit. It went gold in the US, selling 500,000 copies, and reached No.4 on the Billboard chart.

“The first album was a piece of cake,” remembers Hagar, 64 years young and radiating positivity. “We went in there and knocked it out, and it was so easy that I can’t believe it was so good. III was not an easy record.”

You read that right, their second album is called Chickenfoot III. It’s the band’s way of dodging the curse of the ‘difficult second album’. Since the release of the first one, Hagar sold his stake in his beloved Cabo Wabo tequila brand to Gruppo Campari for a cool $80 million, and published his candid autobiography Red: My Uncensored Life In Rock. The book details the darkness behind his bright persona – his troubled youth spent with an abusive father – and his successful, turbulent stint with Van Halen.

“I’d worked pretty hard the year before we made III,” he says. “I’d just done my book tour, which wore me the fuck out. So I didn’t really want to go and make a record, but because of Chad’s schedule we kinda had to.”

Satriani had been squeezing in his Chickenfoot commitments while touring his hit album Black Swans And Wormhole Wizards. “We started this Chickenfoot album with a bit of trouble with our schedules,” he explains. “I was off on tour, and Chad’s commitment with that other band I’m not allowed to mention was looming. That makes everybody focus even more.”

Chickenfoot posing for a photograph in 2011

Chickenfoot in 2011: (from left) Michael Anthony, Sammy Hagar, Joe Satriani (Image credit: Press)

Chickenfoot III was recorded in just four days at Hagar’s studio in Marin County, California. It is indeed a more focused record than the first, and a more textured one. Their debut was a blast of spontaneity and a great surprise, which made it easier to forgive its rougher edges and often jammed-out material. On this follow-up the four-piece finally sound like a band, the songs are more developed and the album has an arc. There’s good-time classic rock in spades – lead-off single Big Foot is a great slice of West Coast fun –balanced by the ruminative blues of Something Going Wrong, the earnest ballad Come Closer, and the experimental Three And A Half Letters on which Hagar uses excerpts from letters he’s received from desperate fans, begging him for help, money, or work.

The cover of Classic Rock magazine issue 163 featuring Jimi Hendrix, Billy Gibbons and David Gilmour

This feature originally appeared in Classic Rock magazine issue 163 (September 2011) (Image credit: Future)

The other side of the coin is Different Devil. A bright, Stonesy anthem, Satriani had a real problem with the initial cheeriness of his demo. He urged the others to make it darker, but they went the other way and made it the most radio-friendly tune on the album. In Chickenfoot, democracy rules. “We don’t have months together,” says Sartiani, “we don’t play on the road much, so everything has to be worked out in a matter of hours and then we move on. If three of the guys say it’s working, I have to get with the program.”

Despite its evasive name, the second album wasn’t without its difficulties. There’s an air of poignancy about it that stems from a human tragedy within the band’s circle. John Carter, Hagar’s long-time personal manager and one of Chickenfoot’s two managers, was diagnosed with cancer during the recording. He died in May, aged 65. “He was my manager and my balance,” says Hagar. “He was the guy I threw the ball against the wall with. Like Joe says, it kinda felt like there was a dark cloud hanging over this album. We wanted to prove something and do something for him. We all cared a lot.”

“It was very hard for all of us,” Satriani adds, “but we weren’t really talking about it. Everyone was just trying to forge ahead, stiff upper lip and all that. When the record was done, Sam and I both started listening to it as a whole, and began to realise why it seemed very difficult at times.”

Fraught with worry for their friend and gaffer, the band pumped their energies into the music. You can hear it in the opening track, Up Next. Over a whittled-down hard rock riff, Hagar is entering Heaven in flip-flops and sunglasses. It’s fun, but it’s also a pointed contemplation of mortality. “With the first record I just did whatever came to mind,” says Hagar. “I didn’t struggle with anything, and it was great and it felt smooth and natural. With this one I didn’t do that with the lyrics. All these songs are personal. Joe and I are the songwriters. We’re the Page and Plant, the Keith Richards and Mick Jagger – we fit right into that mould of guitar/singer songwriting teams.”

Chickenfoot - "Big Foot" (Official Music Video HD) - YouTube Chickenfoot -
Watch On

Again, the two came up with demos and these were then sent to Anthony and Smith. “Chad might say: ‘Can we change this part,’” explains Satriani. “Mike’ll say: ‘I’d like to add this bass line here.’ As we work at it, it moves away from the demo and begins to sound like Chickenfoot. The music we make together is unabashed classic rock. It’s just what happens when we get together. It’s a celebration.”

An integral part of the band’s sound, Mike Anthony’s bass is way up in the mix this time, and he’s in fine voice. “His personality through his bass lines makes some of the songs for me,” the guitarist enthuses. “When we were mastering I was still hearing more and more of it and I’m going: ‘Yeah, listen to that!’ He’s always adding this musicality to everything. He plays through a teeny little amp, and he sounds like six bass players playing together. Then the tone of his voice and where he chooses to sing is unique. There’s no one like him.”

As a rhythm section, Mike Anthony and Chad Smith have clearly found a chemistry. But unfortunately, due to his commitments with the Red Hot Chili Peppers, the drummer won’t be available to tour Chickenfoot III.

“I already miss Chad,” says Hagar. “Everybody thinks that I’m the spark-plug in the band and the energy force behind everything, but when Chad’s around I become the straight guy.”

Chad’s most likely replacement for the tour is Kenny Aronoff, a seasoned session drummer who sometimes sits in for Smith in his other outside-Chilis side project the Meatbats. Hagar is keen to keep the Chickenfoot vibe intact. “Hopefully Mike and Kenny together will develop some kind of chemistry that keeps that craziness going.”

The tour for Chickenfoot was brief – dates in just nine cities – yet it was an education for all the members, not least for Satriani. For his entire solo career he’d stood centre-stage and wailed for two to three hours. Now he was having to accommodate one of the biggest voices in rock. “I’d scratch my head over how different it was to what I’d been doing for the previous 25 years,” he says. “Just simple, basic guitar stuff was so different. Suddenly you have to leave room in the middle for somebody, and then when your part comes you can go crazy, but then you’ve gotta come back.”

Chickenfoot performing live in 2011

Chickenfoot live in 2011 (Image credit: Classic Rock magazine)

“This time we’re gonna do five cities,” says Hagar, “play some smaller venues, and make sure that after one week the chemistry still feels good. And if that’s the case, then we’ll book a world tour. We gotta play this music for the world, man. It’s too good!

“The female side of Chickenfoot’s audience comes from the Wabos [the Waboritas], Van Hagar and my solo career,” Hagar continues. “Joe doesn’t really have a female following. He’s a guitar player – he’s got a bunch of guitar nerds out there, they come. The Chili Peppers fans come a bit, but not really, because they’re an alternative band. We’re a guy band.”

And after that pencilled-in world tour? Well, the jury seems to be out. While Hagar can’t imagine them not writing a pile of songs and recording another album, Satriani feels that part of the focus of the second album comes from the very uncertainty of the band’s future. “Maybe we’re feeling like we’re not going to be doing this forever,” he says. “It’s not like we’re 22 and we feel like the horizon is endless. Everybody knows there’s a finite number of albums. We don’t know how long every band member is actually going to be available. And I have to say, we all have other jobs. From the start this really was for us, because we were getting off on it. If it didn’t work out we could go back to what we were doing. It was a super-bonus that we found our fans.”

“It’s even more fun than you can imagine,” agrees Hagar. “And a lot more fun than being in Van Halen. We took the business out of it. Nobody has ever told us what to do – no record company, no producer, no management. We’re all successful, we’re all fine. So why are we doing this? Because we love it, man. I’d rather be in Chickenfoot than doing anything else.

Originally published in Classic Rock issue 163, September 2011

Grant Moon

A music journalist for over 20 years, Grant writes regularly for titles including Prog, Classic Rock and Total Guitar, and his CV also includes stints as a radio producer/presenter and podcast host. His first book, 'Big Big Train - Between The Lines', is out now through Kingmaker Publishing.

Read more
Them Crooked Vultures posing for a photograph in 2009
“I’ve always embraced my musical schizophrenia, and this is just another room in that mansion of personality”: How Them Crooked Vultures became modern rock’s greatest one-and-done supergroup
Alice In Chains posing for a photograph in 2013
“I can’t see us ever writing songs about boning strippers and doing cocaine in limousine jacuzzis”: How Alice In Chains came to terms with their dark past on The Devil Put Dinosaurs Here
Joe Satriani in sunglasses, pointing at the camera
"We all appeared on stage wearing robes and holding candles:" Joe Satriani on G3 pranking, handling Yngwie Malmsteen and the Halloween costume he'd rather forget
Pearl Jam posing for a photograph in 2013
“This band works like a ouija board. No one’s fully in charge of how it operates, but you keep looking at the letters and seeing what they spell”: How Pearl Jam made Lightning Bolt and embraced their inner Pink Floyd
Von Hertzen Brothers
“We wanted to feel that we weren’t in a rush – even though we were. That’s how you end up singing in a sleeping bag”: From a mountain monastery to a cold bus in a snowstorm, the Von Hertzen Brothers’ Nine Lives was tough work
The Mats Volta studio portrait
"Our band’s chemistry was really coming together. This whole new world opened up to us and we were off drugs. And then Jeremy died": The anarchic early years of one of rock's most enigmatic groups, The Mars Volta
Latest in
Mick Fleetwood and Lindsey Buckingham press photos
Mick Fleetwood and Lindsey Buckingham are working together again
The Darkness wearing business suits
In these troubled times, what we really need is a honky tonk single from The Darkness tackling the issue of male flatulence during lovemaking
Ne Obliviscaris
"Exul ended up being recorded at 10 different studios over two and a half years." Ne Obliviscaris and the heroic story of their fourth album
Mastodon
“We embrace the spirit of early 70s prog as being the way that you should always approach music." Mastodon and their prog epic Crack The Skye
Nancy Wilson
"It's embarrassing to be American now." Heart's Nancy Wilson hits out at America's "salacious billionaire culture" and says it's embarrassing to be an American in 2025
Steven WIlson
"I'm not as humourless as my music!" Steven Wilson announces comedians as support acts for upcoming London Palladium shows
Latest in Features
Ne Obliviscaris
"Exul ended up being recorded at 10 different studios over two and a half years." Ne Obliviscaris and the heroic story of their fourth album
Mastodon
“We embrace the spirit of early 70s prog as being the way that you should always approach music." Mastodon and their prog epic Crack The Skye
Animals As Leaders
"Instrumental albums are often made by musicians for musicians, so we wanted to keep things tuneful and hold the listener’s attention" How Animals As Leaders broke the mould with The Joy Of Motion
Tracks of the Week artists
The best new rock songs you need to hear right now
Robert Fripp and Steven Wilson
“Every record was a battle… I was listening, like, ‘This is amazing!’ but Robert Fripp was reliving the pain and trying to find his way through that”: What Steven Wilson learned from remixing King Crimson
Chickenfoot posing for a photograph in 2011
“It felt like there were dark times hanging over this album”: How hard rock supergroup Chickenfoot restarted the party on their second album, III