Four songs from 200: Part Three

In Classic Rock 200 we counted down the 200 greatest songs of the magazine's lifetime, 1998-2014. Today, it's part three, and Classic Rock's editor Siân Llewellyn writes about four of those songs, and about the bands that made them.

Bruce SpringsteenThe Rising

When we were putting together issue #200, the mag staffers picked their favourite album of Classic Rock’s lifetime. And it was a really tough ask. There’s been some incredible music released over the last 16 years. In the end, I whittled it down to a shortlist, and as I truly couldn’t decide (seriously, we’re talking sleepless nights here), I decided to take the matter out of my own hands and let science decide – ie, I consulted the ‘most played’ button on my iPod and let that make the choice from my nominees.

Technology decreed that Bruce Springsteen & The E Street Band’s The Rising was the one. It’s an album I adore. In fact, I think it’s a masterpiece. From Bruce reuniting with the E Street Band to its impeccable songcraft to the way it tackles tragedy in a manner that’s cathartic and never mawkish. It’s triumphant and melancholy, devastating and uplifting. More often than not, all at the same time.

Ryan AdamsNew York, New York

Another record on my album shortlist was Ryan Adams’ Gold. Four days before the Twin Towers fell and the world changed on September 11, 2001, the former Whiskeytown man ventured to Brooklyn to shoot the video for his ode to my favourite city. Armed with an acoustic guitar, Adams with the proud Manhattan skyline as his backdrop sings of Avenue A, the upper west side and his love for this most atmospheric of towns. It’s a fantastic song, full of melody, fond farewells and meaning, made all the more poignant thanks to the film clip.

Oh, and Adams did a brilliant piano version at Abbey Road Studios.

The Civil Wars — Barton Hollow

It’s funny the way you discover new music, even when you work on a magazine and things get sent to you every day.

Back in 2011, Metal Hammer Editor In Chief Alex Milas and I bonded over this haunting folk rock duo. Here’s how it went…

On 5 Oct 2011, at 12:46 pm, Alexander Milas wrote: Heard of them? If not check out Barton Hollow on YouTube. Love it.

On 5 Oct 2011, at 12:56 pm, Sian Llewellyn wrote: Ha ha. VERY much heard of them! Aren’t they great? Brilliant stuff.

On 6 Oct 2011, at 11:19 am, Alexander Milas wrote: And yes, I am completely loving them - wonderful band, need the record! Just picked up on a bit of a buzz after their appearance on Jools earlier this week and I’m totally into them.

On 6 Oct 2011, at 11:32 am, Sian Llewellyn wrote: They really are. I bought it from iTunes back in the summer when Barton Hollow was single of the week on the US iTunes store. I hadn’t realised they were on Jools. Will have to catch it on the iPlayer…

And so it went on. And on. And on a bit more. In fact, every now and then, Alex and I still talk of how bloody marvellous The Civil Wars were. They boiled rock to its barest blues-based essentials and made it their own. Check ‘em out.

The ReplacementsPool & Dive (2006)

I fell head over heels in love with The Replacements when I bought a bright blue vinyl copy of Let It Be on a whim a million years ago. Instantly taken with Paul Westerberg’s ramshackle way with a tune and the musical knife edge the band seemed to walk - one move the wrong way and it’d all fall apart – I went on to devour everything I could find. Fast forward a few years, I’m working on Classic Rock and The ‘Mats as a going concern is nothing but a distant memory. Westerberg was turning in solo albums (in the most part, superb ones too), but still, I wanted his old band back. Then, out of nowhere in 2006, arrives news of a Greatest Hits collection. Yeah, yeah, yeah, that’s all well and good, but what I wanted was something new, but that was never gonna happen, was it? Bob Stinson had died in 1995, Tommy Stinson had been playing bass and acting as MD for GN’R since ’98 and Chris Mars had been concentrating on his painting and showed little interest in returning to music. But, lo, somehow the press release revealed that Westerberg, Stinson and Mars (the latter on backing vox rather than his usual drums) had got together and recorded two brand new songs. Woah. Then I panicked. ‘What if they’re shit?!’ ‘Nah, they won’t be shit’ ‘But what if they are?’ ran my internal monologue. But I needn’t have worried. Both new songs - Message To The Boys and Pool & Dive (the song that made our list) - were perfect slices of Replacements magic.

Read Part One.

Read Part Two.

**You can view the entire 200 tracks in issue 200 of Classic Rock, which can be ordered online from MyFavouriteMagazines. **

**Alternatively, you can download the Classic Rock magazine app from iTunes. **

Siân Llewellyn
Editor, Classic Rock

Classic Rock editor Siân has worked on the magazine for longer than she cares to discuss, and prior to that was deputy editor of Total Guitar. During that time, she’s had the chance to interview artists such as Brian May, Slash, Jeff Beck, James Hetfield, Sammy Hagar, Alice Cooper, Manic Street Preachers and countless more. She has hosted The Classic Rock Magazine Show on both TotalRock and TeamRock radio, contributed to CR’s The 20 Million Club podcast and has also had bylines in Metal Hammer, Guitarist, Total Film, Cult TV and more. When not listening to, playing, thinking or writing about music, she can be found getting increasingly more depressed about the state of the Welsh national rugby team and her beloved Pittsburgh Steelers.

Latest in
Adrian Smith performing with Iron Maiden in 2024
Adrian Smith names his favourite Iron Maiden song, even though it’s “awkward” to play
Robert Smith, Lauren Mayberry, Bono
How your purchase of albums by The Cure, U2, Chvrches and more on Record Store Day can help benefit children living in war zones worldwide
Cradle Of Filth performing in 2021 and Ed Sheeran in 2024
Cradle Of Filth’s singer claims Ed Sheeran tried to turn a Toys R Us into a live music venue
The Beatles in 1962
"The quality is unreal. How is this even possible to have?" Record shop owner finds 1962 Beatles' audition tape that a British label famously decided wasn't good enough to earn Lennon and McCartney's band a record deal
The Mars Volta
“My totalitarian rule might not be cool, but at least we’ve made interesting records. At least we polarise people”: It took The Mars Volta three years and several arguments to make Noctourniquet
/news/the-darkness-i-hate-myself
"When the storm clouds clear, the band’s innate pop sensibilities shine as brightly as ever": In a world of bread-and-butter rock bands, The Darkness remain the toast of the town
Latest in Features
The Mars Volta
“My totalitarian rule might not be cool, but at least we’ve made interesting records. At least we polarise people”: It took The Mars Volta three years and several arguments to make Noctourniquet
Ginger Wildheart headshot
"What happens next, you give everyone a hard-on and then go around the room with a bat like Al Capone?!” Ginger Wildheart's wild tales of Lemmy, AC/DC, Guns N' Roses, Cheap Trick and more
Crispian Mills and Bob Ezrin
“We spent seven months on David Gilmour’s boat and almost bankrupted ourselves. But Bob encouraged us to dream big”: How Bob Ezrin brought out the prog in Kula Shaker
Buckethead and Axl Rose onstage
Psychic tests! Pet wolves! Chicken coops! Guns N' Roses and the wild ride towards Chinese Democracy
Ne Obliviscaris
"Exul ended up being recorded at 10 different studios over two and a half years." Ne Obliviscaris and the heroic story of their fourth album
Mastodon 2000s press shot
“We embrace the spirit of early 70s prog as being the way that you should always approach music." Mastodon and their prog epic Crack The Skye