“That was high school for me!” Watch Carrie Underwood team with an American Idol contestant to cover Drowning Pool’s nu metal banger Bodies

Carrie Underwood in 2025
(Image credit: Todd Owyoung/NBC via Getty Images)

US country favourite Carrie Underwood has helped an American Idol contestant cover Bodies by Drowning Pool.

The 42-year-old, who won American Idol in 2005 and now judges on the talent show, joined a contestant called ‘Insite’ in singing the 2001 nu metal floor-filler on the latest episode. The 18-year-old music teacher from Florida also did a rendition of Freak On A Leash by Korn. Watch the footage of his performances below.

After the seemingly impromptu Bodies team-up, Underwood tells her fellow judges Lionel Richie and Luke Bryan that she’s something of a secret metal fan. “That was high school for me!” she says of the Drowning Pool track, before adding: “I’ve even crowd-surfed people, OK?”

You may like

“We are learning about our [fellow] judge,” Richie quips in response.

After the audition, Insite is unanimously voted through to the competition’s second round, which is called “Hollywood Week” and sees contestants perform in front of the judges once again, sometimes in pairs.

Bryan asks Underwood after the audition, “What is your mother gonna say when she sees this?”

“She knows,” she replies.

Drowning Pool released Bodies in May 2001 as the lead single of their debut album Sinner. It was an instant hit, reaching number 34 in the UK and 6 on the US Mainstream Rock chart. That commercial ascent coincided with the band’s appearance on the 2001 Ozzfest tour and got them pushed further up the bill.

Guitarist C.J. Pierce told Metal Hammer in 2023: “Sharon Osbourne ended up moving us up the bill of Ozzfest while we were on the tour. We did the Jägermeister tour straight after, then Music As A Weapon with Disturbed. These were huge arena crowds, but every night we’d go out and do Bodies and you’d see the whole place go up.”

After 9/11, US radio conglomerate Clear Channel tried to get Bodies banned in the US, deeming its lyrics inappropriate for the contemporary cultural climate.

Bassist Stevie Benton remembered in 2023: “It’s always really frustrated me that people took this song – that was about kids at a rock show – and put all these negative connotations on it. When Clear Channel just struck it off, they made it seem like there was a reason for it to be banned. It took away the ambiguity of the song and people’s ability to decide on the meaning for themselves.”

Drowning Pool’s original vocalist Dave Williams died from heart disease in 2002, but the band continue to tour and record. They released single Revolution (The Final Amen) with frontman Ryan McCombs in September and plan to put out their eighth studio album this year.

Insite Audition | Freak On A Leash + Bodies | Full Performance | American Idol 2025 - YouTube Insite Audition | Freak On A Leash + Bodies | Full Performance | American Idol 2025 - YouTube
Watch On
Matt Mills
Contributing Editor, Metal Hammer

Louder’s resident Gojira obsessive was still at uni when he joined the team in 2017. Since then, Matt’s become a regular in Prog and Metal Hammer, at his happiest when interviewing the most forward-thinking artists heavy music can muster. He’s got bylines in The Guardian, The Telegraph, NME, Guitar and many others, too. When he’s not writing, you’ll probably find him skydiving, scuba diving or coasteering.

Read more
Knocked Loose band shot 2024
"Slipknot took care of us!" Knocked Loose's Bryan Garris on rubbing shoulders with metal icons, taking hardcore mainstream and what comes next
Knocked Loose at the Grammys
"The second we got the offer for Jimmy Kimmel I said, 'I'm gonna pig squeal on national television!'" Knocked Loose singer Bryan Garris on the Grammys, THAT performance with Poppy and conquering a phobia to bring heavy music to the mainstream
Brat press pic
"My first concert was The Black Crowes, but my second was ZZ Top. That would've been the cooler answer!" Brat's Liz Selfish: 10 Records That Changed My Life
Halestorm posing for a photograph in 2015
“The one core thing about metal is that rebellious nature. You’re allowed to be yourself no matter what side of the spectrum you are”: How Halestorm went from teenage rockers to globe-conquering metal stars
Halsey in 2024
Pop megastar Halsey booked hardcore shows when she was 16
Pat Boone
"To whatever extent somebody was wounded, I am very sorry": That time Pat Boone went metal and the Christian community got really mad
Latest in
Carrie Underwood in 2025
“That was high school for me!” Watch Carrie Underwood team with an American Idol contestant to cover Drowning Pool’s nu metal banger Bodies
Lacuna Coil in 2025
"Someone said, 'Ozzy and Sharon would like to say hi'. I was so starstruck!" From Ozzfest and partying with Bullet For My Valentine to stalkers and dodgy photoshoots, Lacuna Coil put Italian metal on the map
Metal Hammer New Heavy bundles
Order your exclusive Slaughter To Prevail, Jinjer, Electric Callboy, Bloodywood and Bambie Thug bundles, featuring limited edition t-shirts, longsleeves and spellbooks
Katatonia
Katatonia announce European tour dates for November and December
Randy Blythe in 2024 and Elon Musk in 2025
“If we are afraid to say, ‘Hey, that’s not cool,’ we’re screwed”: Lamb Of God’s Randy Blythe gives another scathing takedown of Elon Musk
Kate Bush
“If you look at it, it’s my reputation… I need five months to prepare a show, and I can’t be writing new songs or promoting the album”: Is this why Kate Bush only ever toured once?
Latest in News
Carrie Underwood in 2025
“That was high school for me!” Watch Carrie Underwood team with an American Idol contestant to cover Drowning Pool’s nu metal banger Bodies
Metal Hammer New Heavy bundles
Order your exclusive Slaughter To Prevail, Jinjer, Electric Callboy, Bloodywood and Bambie Thug bundles, featuring limited edition t-shirts, longsleeves and spellbooks
Katatonia
Katatonia announce European tour dates for November and December
Randy Blythe in 2024 and Elon Musk in 2025
“If we are afraid to say, ‘Hey, that’s not cool,’ we’re screwed”: Lamb Of God’s Randy Blythe gives another scathing takedown of Elon Musk
Tool in 2023
Lawyer considers class action lawsuit as Tool fans express anger over setlist choices for Dominican Republic two-night event
Nova Twins, 2025
“The industry often pits women against each other, and women’s voices are silenced worldwide. But we are still shouting from the rooftops!” Nova Twins share new single Soprano, reveal album details plus UK and Europe headline tour itinerary