David Gilmour reveals what he thinks are the best lyrics Roger Waters ever wrote for Pink Floyd, choosing lyrics his former bandmate Waters considers “appalling”

David Gilmour, Roger Waters
(Image credit: Dave M. Benett/CI Getty Images Entertainment)

David Gilmour has somewhat mischievously nominated the very first song Roger Waters ever wrote as the best lyrics his former Pink Floyd bandmate ever penned. 

Waters and Gilmour have been at loggerheads for years, but Gilmour had the opportunity to pay his former friend and bandmate a compliment when, during a readers' interview conducted for The Guardian, a reader employing the pseudonym 'evermost' asked, 'What were some of the best lyrics you think Roger ever wrote?'

“Gosh, let me have a think about that,” the vocalist/guitarist ponders, before offering, “How about a song called Walk With Me Sydney?”

When Guardian writer Christopher Lord tells Gilmour that he's not familiar with the lyrics in question, Gilmour laughs and replies, “I’m not surprised. I don’t think it’s officially recorded.”

The song in question was actually written by Waters in 1965, and the song's author remembers the lyrics as “appalling”. 

Speaking with The Times in 2015, for a feature celebrating 50 years of Pink Floyd, Waters said, “I sang my first song on a Tube train, busking to get money for student Rag Week... It was written to be sung by a girl and called Walk With Me Sydney - relating, yes, to Syd Barrett.”

You may like

Asked by writer Alex O'Connel if he could remember the tune, Waters broke into song, saying: “Ha! I’m afraid I can. It went, 'Waaalk with me, Sydney/ I’d love to, love to, love to, baby you know/ Sydney, it’s a daaark night, hold me, hold me hold me tight/ I’d love to, love to, love to/ But I got flat feet and fallen arches and peritonitis and DT’s and a washed up braaaain...

“It was appalling,” Waters admitted, adding with a laugh, “They don’t write songs like that any more, son!”

Listen to Walk With Me Sydney below.

Walk With Me Sydney - 1965 - YouTube Walk With Me Sydney - 1965 - YouTube
Watch On

Earlier this week it was revealed that Pink Floyd have struck a deal to sell the rights to their recorded music catalogue.

According to The Financial Times, who broke the news, the deal with Sony is worth 400 million dollars and includes Pink Floyd’s recorded music, the band name and the artists’ “likeness”, meaning that the label will have the rights to merchandise and spin-offs.

Last month, David Gilmour declared that it would be a "dream" of his to sell the band's catalogue.

Paul Brannigan
Contributing Editor, Louder

A music writer since 1993, formerly Editor of Kerrang! and Planet Rock magazine (RIP), Paul Brannigan is a Contributing Editor to Louder. Having previously written books on Lemmy, Dave Grohl (the Sunday Times best-seller This Is A Call) and Metallica (Birth School Metallica Death, co-authored with Ian Winwood), his Eddie Van Halen biography (Eruption in the UK, Unchained in the US) emerged in 2021. He has written for Rolling Stone, Mojo and Q, hung out with Fugazi at Dischord House, flown on Ozzy Osbourne's private jet, played Angus Young's Gibson SG, and interviewed everyone from Aerosmith and Beastie Boys to Young Gods and ZZ Top. Born in the North of Ireland, Brannigan lives in North London and supports The Arsenal.

Read more
David Gilmour photographed at an outdoor festival in 1971
“I had some criticisms of Dark Side Of The Moon. One or two of the vehicles carrying the ideas were not as strong as the ideas that they carried”: How David Gilmour attempted to lay the ghost of Pink Floyd to rest
Dabid Gilmour in 1978, 1984 and 2024
David Gilmour solo albums: the essential guide
Pink Floyd standing on a bridge in a Japanese garden
Every Pink Floyd album ranked from worst to best
David Gilmour - David Gilmour cover art
"As a guitarist he has few peers but as a songwriter he's no Roger Waters": David Gilmour soars on beautifully crafted if ultimately unchallenging debut solo album
Roger Waters - The Dark Side of the Moon Redux Deluxe Box Set
“The live recording sees the piece come to life… amid the sepulchral gloom there are moments of real beauty”: Roger Waters' Super Deluxe Box Set of his Dark Side Of The Moon Redux
“People would say, ‘He took a trip and now he’s weird.’ He wasn’t weird at all”: Mick Rock’s “surprisingly simple” friendship with Syd Barrett, and other psychedelic adventures
Latest in
Foreigner at the Rock and Roll Hall Of Fame in 2024
Foreigner will complete their Historic Farewell Tour with four different singers – and one of them has recorded Spanish versions of their hits
Linkin Park 2024
Linkin Park launch "the best song we've ever made" Up From The Bottom
Vera Farmiga in 2021
The Conjuring star Vera Farmiga announces debut album with her heavy metal band The Yagas
'Emo' Ed Sheeran busking
Watch Ed Sheeran cover Chappell Roan's Pink Pony Club on the New York subway while disguised as an emo busker
A close-up shot of the Marshall Major IV on-ear headphones on a turquoise, blue and black background.
I’ve never seen the Marshall Major IV headphones this cheap before - get them for half price in Amazon’s big spring sale
Evanescence in 2025
Evanescence release new song Afterlife from Devil May Cry TV series soundtrack, have their next album in the works
Latest in News
Foreigner at the Rock and Roll Hall Of Fame in 2024
Foreigner will complete their Historic Farewell Tour with four different singers – and one of them has recorded Spanish versions of their hits
Linkin Park 2024
Linkin Park launch "the best song we've ever made" Up From The Bottom
Vera Farmiga in 2021
The Conjuring star Vera Farmiga announces debut album with her heavy metal band The Yagas
'Emo' Ed Sheeran busking
Watch Ed Sheeran cover Chappell Roan's Pink Pony Club on the New York subway while disguised as an emo busker
A close-up shot of the Marshall Major IV on-ear headphones on a turquoise, blue and black background.
I’ve never seen the Marshall Major IV headphones this cheap before - get them for half price in Amazon’s big spring sale
Evanescence in 2025
Evanescence release new song Afterlife from Devil May Cry TV series soundtrack, have their next album in the works