“Although it continues the ongoing Amory Wars saga, this is a starker, slicker, highly polished gem of a record”: Coheed And Cambria mix the personal and the cosmic on new album The Father Of Make Believe

Coheed And Cambria retain their sci-fi prog metal crown on The Father Of Make Believe

Coheed And Cambria: The Father Of Make Believe album cover
(Image: © Virgin Music Group)

You can trust Louder Our experienced team has worked for some of the biggest brands in music. From testing headphones to reviewing albums, our experts aim to create reviews you can trust. Find out more about how we review.

Midlife does strange things to people, not least wondering what’s next, and time to reflect on what’s gone before. At 46, Coheed And Cambria singer and guitarist Claudio Sanchez has created what he refers to as his “midlife crisis record” with The Father Of Make Believe. Better this than a second-hand Porsche or a ‘Death Or Glory’ tattoo.

Although it continues the ongoing saga of the band’s Amory Wars story, and the album ends with a suite of songs set in that universe, this is a starker, slicker, highly polished gem of a record. Lots more of Sanchez himself. The lilting Meri Of Mercy is a paean to his late grandparents. The gambolling and great Searching For Tomorrow, which charts the singer’s creative arc, is a set opener if ever there was one. That and the euphoric Someone Who Can could top and tail any show. The acoustic Corner My Confidence is an open love letter to Sanchez’s wife, and as far from the star-bursting imagery and folklore the band built a part of their legend on as you can imagine. It’s a remarkable evolutionary step forward.

Coheed and Cambria - "Someone Who Can" [Official Video] - YouTube Coheed and Cambria -
Watch On
Read more
Coheed and Cambria in 2024
The Father Of Make Believe is Coheed And Cambria's midlife crisis album. Luckily, it's also a layered, thoughtful and rich new entry in the Amory Wars Saga
The cover of Steven Wilson’s The Overview album
“A return to full-fat prog from the man who gave the genre a good name in recent years”: Prog fans rejoice! Steven Wilson has come home with cosmic modern classic The Overview
Devin Townsend
“I thought it was just going to be a fun little party record, but my grief started leaching into the music”: Devin Townsend is slightly embarrassed by his new album, and that’s a good thing
The Wildhearts: Satanic Rites Of The Wildhearts
“An ode to the litany of wankers we all have to deal with every day”: The Wildhearts prove once again they’re one of the UK’s greatest bands with The Satanic Rites Of…
Tremonti
"If this album had been released 25 years ago, it would have been a revelation." New Tremonti record The End Will Show Us How is just about what you'd expect, but it's pretty damn good all the same
Steven Wilson – The Overview
“Nothing overshadows the totality of the concept… The Overview is very prog indeed”: Steven Wilson fully embraces the genre again, in a modern manner that will attract new listeners
Latest in
Justin Hayward & Mike Batt
Justin Hayward hooks up with Mike Batt to cover Dream Academy's Life In A Northern Town
Di'Anno and Harris
“Paul liked to ruffle a few feathers. He used to call me Hitler. I’ve been called Sergeant Major, but Hitler takes the biscuit.” Iron Maiden's Steve Harris remembers "lovable rogue" Paul Di'Anno
Spiritbox
Courtney LaPlante on the sense of "existential dread" that fuelled new Spiritbox album Tsunami Sea
Oasis in 2024
Oasis announce Live ’25 reunion tour film to be produced by Peaky Blinders creator
Steven WIlson
“Once you realise your existence is futile and life is a random gift, you think, ‘I’m going to make the most of it.’ Life is meaningless – so embrace it”: Steven Wilson looks back at Planet Earth
Cyndi Lauper in 2025 and Mikael Stanne in 2024
Ever wanted to hear Cyndi Lauper go goth? Try this cover of I Drove All Night by Scandi supergroup Cemetery Skyline
Latest in Review
Steven Wilson – The Overview
“Nothing overshadows the totality of the concept… The Overview is very prog indeed”: Steven Wilson fully embraces the genre again, in a modern manner that will attract new listeners
Coheed and Cambria in 2024
The Father Of Make Believe is Coheed And Cambria's midlife crisis album. Luckily, it's also a layered, thoughtful and rich new entry in the Amory Wars Saga
The Murder Capital, 2025
Blindness cements The Murder Capital's standing as one of Ireland’s great modern guitar bands
Jon Anderson & The Band Geeks: Live – Perpetual Change album cover
“Has his voice withstood the test of time? The answer is an emphatic yes”: Jon Anderson effortlessly recreates the best of Yes on new album Live – Perpetual Change
Dorothy: The Way album cover
“There’s nothing here we haven’t heard before, but the band’s laser-focused endeavour is almost tangible”: 10 years in, Dorothy delivers her best album yet with The Way
Coheed & Cambria: The Father Of Make Believe album cover
“Although it continues the ongoing Amory Wars saga, this is a starker, slicker, highly polished gem of a record”: Coheed And Cambria mix the personal and the cosmic on new album The Father Of Make Believe