"As unmistakable contemporary backing vocals from McCartney intertwine with Lennon, an involuntary emotional response is utterly inevitable." Classic Rock's Reviews Editor and biggest Beatles fan gives his verdict on Now And Then

Classic Rock Reviews Editor Ian Fortnam gives his take on the song everyone is talking about

The Beatles surrounded by flowers
(Image: © Apple Corps Ltd)

You can trust Louder Our experienced team has worked for some of the biggest brands in music. From testing headphones to reviewing albums, our experts aim to create reviews you can trust. Find out more about how we review.

When it comes to big deals, the release of a new Beatles song is about as big as a deal can get.  After all, not only are The Beatles the biggest selling artists in history (183 million units of certified sales and counting), they’ve also not favoured us with a brand new tune for 27 years.  It’s also, we’re told - by no less an authority than Paul McCartney - ‘The Last Beatles Song’. And this is why we’ve been comprehensively teaser-ed to within an inch of our very lives over the course of the last few days in the run up to its release. 

First there was ‘The Announcement’. Cue media meltdown.  After all, The Rolling Stones may well have trademarked ‘The Greatest Rock ’N’ Roll Band In The World’ for themselves, but this…well, this is The Beatles.

Then ‘The Short Film’ which lathered up The Beatles’ faithful fan base no end with its pacily-edited, appetite-whetting clips of the Fabs in their heyday, the surviving ’95 Threatles sceptically stroking their chins over the potential of John Lennon’s raw, primitive, piano-masked, Yoko-sourced demo cassette, prior to an emotionally charged revelation of his beautifully fragile lead vocal (uncannily isolated by Get Back director Peter Jackson and his team). 

Then there’s today’s McCartney and Ringo Starr properly enthusing over the project and, be still our beating hearts, even a blink-and-you-miss-it snippet of the finished product. The poignantly titled Now And Then. So, now that all the news outlets and hype merchants have thoroughly lubed us all up, comes the moment of truth, where the music has to finally speak for itself.

Headline! It starts, as all the best songs should, with a 1-2... Before the simple piano riff (familiar from the ‘short film’ and a billion dodgy clandestinely shared bootlegs of the Lennon home demo), now pin-sharp in its newly played by McCartney incarnation before the miraculously recovered Lennon vocal announces itself with “I know it’s true, it’s all because of you/And if I make it through it’s all because of you.” 

It sounds an awful lot like a lyric being sung for Yoko, rather than for posterity, but it is classic Lennon. And as the song unfolds it’s clearly laced with a singular melancholia characteristic of Lennon’s solo work of the time. In its original demo form, accompanied only by heavy, halting piano chords, it bordered on the maudlin, but as its meticulously crafted (largely by McCartney) setting unfolds it surely gains an emotional weight that renders it more than worthy of its Beatles mantle. 

Bridging toward its second verse Ringo enters the fray, subtly rim-shotting the down-tempo beat as the familiarly warm richness of McCartney’s Hofner violin bass lifts the mood.

As the chorus hits, Ringo - never a workmanlike four-to-the-floor beat-keeper - reacts with an adept flourish, Giles Martin-arranged strings (a signature Beatles move from Yesterday to Across The Universe) swell and as unmistakable contemporary backing vocals from McCartney intertwine with Lennon, an involuntary emotional response is utterly inevitable.   

Following a second chorus, wherein the kitchen-sink’s worth of production never intrudes to the core composition’s detriment, comes McCartney’s slide guitar solo, inspired by George Harrison’s original ’95 sound sketches but played by Macca in George’s gloriously understated style. Always serving the song, never the ego, it’s an affecting, appropriate tribute to one of the least lauded of rock music’s enduringly influential guitar stylists, lost to cancer in 2001, that lifts the song into the stratosphere, before a soaring combo of strings, sensitive near-choral gang vocals lead into (with all due deference to the Ramones) a third verse, same as the first, before an all hands to the pumps coda that finally hits the buffers in an extremely Beatles, exceptionally ingenious style. 

So should they have done it? Is it pushing the boundaries of what constitutes a Beatles record too far? Ultimately, The Beatles were always at the very forefront of audio technology; their forthright embrace of new sounds and state-of-the-art recording techniques that progressed pop toward rock is, in many ways, why we’re all here. 

Would John Lennon have approved of the means by which his final Beatles-enhanced words to the world were finally delivered? One would hope so. For as Sean Ono Lennon would have it, he was “Never shy to experiment with audio technology”.

Whatever: Now And Then, the last Beatles song has finally arrived, and it’s more than worth the wait.

Ian Fortnam
Reviews Editor, Classic Rock

Classic Rock’s Reviews Editor for the last 20 years, Ian stapled his first fanzine in 1977. Since misspending his youth by way of ‘research’ his work has also appeared in such publications as Metal Hammer, Prog, NME, Uncut, Kerrang!, VOX, The Face, The Guardian, Total Guitar, Guitarist, Electronic Sound, Record Collector and across the internet. Permanently buried under mountains of recorded media, ears ringing from a lifetime of gigs, he enjoys nothing more than recreationally throttling a guitar and following a baptism of punk fire has played in bands for 45 years, releasing recordings via Esoteric Antenna and Cleopatra Records.

Read more
Peter Gabriel with Genesis
“Peter Gabriel started singing over my solos. I was pissed off – ‘You’re singing on my bit!’ But that half-minute is probably our peak”: How Genesis made Supper’s Ready, arguably their greatest song
Detail from the album cover of Bob Dylan's Bringing It All Back home
“If you don’t like Bringing It All Back Home, you don’t like music. You should hand your ears back.” Bob Dylan’s game-changing album is 60 today and still astonishing
David Gilmour - David Gilmour cover art
"As a guitarist he has few peers but as a songwriter he's no Roger Waters": David Gilmour soars on beautifully crafted if ultimately unchallenging debut solo album
Talking Heads: Remain In Light cover art
"After a lifetime listening to hard rock and heavy metal I discovered Talking Heads and realised how good music could really be": Talking Heads open up new worlds on Remain In Light
Marillion
“I thought I’d have to sell my house. The manager suggested we got part-time jobs”: Marillion were facing oblivion. Then they made This Strange Engine and found a way forward
David Gilmour in front of a wooden fence
"I did start by saying: 'Do we need another guitar solo here?'" David Gilmour on boomer fortune and the making of Luck And Strange
Latest in
Foreigner at the Rock and Roll Hall Of Fame in 2024
Foreigner will complete their Historic Farewell Tour with four different singers – and one of them has recorded Spanish versions of their hits
Pete Townshend - The Studio Albums cover art
"This collection embodies both the best and worst of Townshend the artist and arch conceptualist": An overview of the solo career of Pete Townshend, the man who never meant to have a solo career
Linkin Park 2024
Linkin Park launch "the best song we've ever made" Up From The Bottom
Vera Farmiga in 2021
The Conjuring star Vera Farmiga announces debut album with her heavy metal band The Yagas
'Emo' Ed Sheeran busking
Watch Ed Sheeran cover Chappell Roan's Pink Pony Club on the New York subway while disguised as an emo busker
A close-up shot of the Marshall Major IV on-ear headphones on a turquoise, blue and black background.
I’ve never seen the Marshall Major IV headphones this cheap before - get them for half price in Amazon’s big spring sale
Latest in Review
Pete Townshend - The Studio Albums cover art
"This collection embodies both the best and worst of Townshend the artist and arch conceptualist": An overview of the solo career of Pete Townshend, the man who never meant to have a solo career
The Horrors
Ghouls Aloud: The Horrors come back from the dead with "a dazzling nocturnal spectacle of sombre reflections and oozing catharsis"
/news/the-darkness-i-hate-myself
"When the storm clouds clear, the band’s innate pop sensibilities shine as brightly as ever": In a world of bread-and-butter rock bands, The Darkness remain the toast of the town
Sex Pistols at the RAH
"Open the dance floor, you’ll never get to do it again." Forget John Lydon's bitter and boring "karaoke" jibes, with Frank Carter up front, the Sex Pistols sound like the world's greatest punk band once more
Arch Enemy posing in an alleyway
Arch Enemy promised they'd throw out the rule book for Blood Dynasty. They didn't go quite that far, but this is the boldest album of the Alissa White-Gluz era - and it kicks ass
The Darkness press shot
"Not just one of the best British rock albums of all time, but one of the best debut albums ever made": That time The Darkness added a riot of colour to a grey musical landscape